The Truth About The Island Of The Dolls

The Truth About The Island Of The Dolls


June 27, 2024 | Sarah Ng

The Truth About The Island Of The Dolls


Real-Life Horror

Without a doubt, La Isla de las Muñecas, or "The Island of the Dolls," is like a horror film come to life.

Dolls-Msn

Advertisement

Dark Tourism At Its Finest

Completely covered in dirty and battered dolls, the island—located south of the center of Mexico City—already has an air of terror. However, its haunting history makes it a must-see destination for paranormal enthusiasts, and today, it's a thriving tourist attraction.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, Mexicomarketa1982, Shutterstock

Advertisement

The Origin Story

To understand why and how The Island of the Dolls came to be, one must understand the heart-wrenching story of Don Julian Santana Barrera.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoEsparta Palma, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

He Was Unstable

Reportedly, Barrera moved to the island in the 1950s, leaving his wife and family behind. Though his reasons for isolating himself are difficult to pinpoint, some sources say that he was mentally unwell.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoKatyaMSL, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Finding Her Body

It wasn't long after moving that Barrera made the most upsetting discovery imaginable: He found a girl's body in the canals.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoWa17gs, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Drowning In The Water Lilies

The young girl is said to have drowned after getting caught in the water lilies. This awful event altered Barrera's life and the island's fate forever.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoWa17gs, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

He Found Her Doll

The next day, Barrera made another discovery. This time, it was a doll floating in the canals. Assuming that this doll likely belonged to the girl he'd found the day before, he made a strange decision.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoEneas De Troya, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Her Spirit Haunted Him

To honor the young girl and keep her spirit happy, Barrera strung her doll up in a tree. However, as the legend goes, the dead girl continued to haunt the island and Barrera himself.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoEmmanuel Eslava, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The Creepiest Dolls

Barrera claimed that dolls began appearing in the trees over time—and some of them were downright chilling to look at as they were missing crucial body parts. But that was just the tip of the iceberg.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoPx-lga, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Appeasing Her Spirit

In lieu of some bad luck and his failed crops, Barrera continued to look for dolls to appease the girl's spirit. In a way, the island became his twisted shrine.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoPx-lga, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Looking For More

Barrera went to extreme lengths to gather as many dolls as he could, even rummaging through garbage and looking in the canals. He even used the produce he grew in his personal garden, trading the vegetables for more dolls.

The dolls Barrera found came in a variety of states—and many of them were already shabby and terrifying to look at.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoPx-lga, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

They Got Scarier Over Time

At the mercy of the elements, these dolls have only grown more unnerving with time—and is one of the reasons it's become a center for dark tourism.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoEmmanuel Eslava, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

A Way To Protect Himself

For five decades, Barrera's doll collection began to overrun the island. And though we may consider them "haunted" today, Barrera probably saw them as necessary measures for his own protection.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoWa17gs, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The End Of Barrera

In 2001, a chilling incident came to pass. When Barrera's nephew came to visit, he took him fishing in the canal.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoPx-lga, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

He Spoke Of Mermaids

While fishing, 80-year-old Barrera began exuberantly singing, but also made some unsettling comments. He began saying odd things, talking about how there were mermaids beckoning to him from the water. 

However, it wasn't until Barrera's nephew left him alone for a short time that things went wrong.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoEmmanuel Eslava, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

His Very Own Tragedy

When the nephew returned to his uncle's side, a tragedy awaited him. He found Barrera's body in the canal—face down. But that wasn't all.

Photo of Creepy old doll in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoEmmanuel Eslava, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

He Died In The Same Place

Apparently, Barrera lost his life in roughly the same location that the young girl drowned—all those years ago.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoEmmanuel Eslava, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

How Did He Die?

Obviously, the public has wildly speculated about the cause of Barrera's death, which range from a heart attack to drowning. True believers of the island's haunting even point fingers at the girl's spirit.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoDante 51, Flickr

Advertisement

The Dolls Move On Their Own

Those who live locally have made some jaw-dropping claims about the dolls themselves. Some say that the dolls become animated during the night.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoAndrea Di Castro, Flickr

Advertisement

They Whisper To Each Other

There have been eerie reports of the dolls moving on their own, turning their heads—even whistling and whispering. Of course, the non-believers would just blame the wind.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoNoel Cecil, Flickr

Advertisement

Making Offerings

Those who visit the island have been known to offer things to the dolls. Some even change the dolls' clothes, and maintain a sense of reverence for the island and its history.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoWa17gs, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons 

Advertisement

Bring Your Own Doll

Since Barrera's passing, tourists have continued to honor his memory by bringing their own dolls to the island and stringing them up alongside all the others.

Photo of Creepy old dolls in the abandoned Island of the Dolls, Xochimilco, MexicoKevin, Flickr

Advertisement

READ MORE

Glacier - Fb

Scientists are using advanced technology to understand the terrifying and mysterious noises from deep within glaciers.

Glaciers speak differently; in ways most people never hear. With sensors and microphones, glaciologists have captured clicks and rumbles from deep inside the ice. Each sound connects to a movement or a change.
July 15, 2025 Alex Summers
Intro

Excavations in northern Benin revealed a large iron-smelting site, confirming the region’s role in West Africa’s early metallurgy.

The clues weren’t in scrolls. They were buried in ash and clay. It turns out that some of the most powerful changes in history start with fire and the minds that manage it.
July 14, 2025 Miles Brucker
HAPAG-Dampfschiff Prinzessin Victoria Luise

The Horrifying Story Of The First Cruise Ship

The Titanic. The Lusitania. The Costa Concordia. We all know about these horrifying maritime tragedies, but few remember the chilling history of the Prinzessin Victoria Luise. Not only was it the first ever cruise ship—it was also the first cruise ship disaster.
July 17, 2025 Penelope Singh
Dian Fossey in 1983

Dian Fossey Met A Chilling End

Dian Fossey was one of history's most famous primatologists—but she met the most disturbing end possible. This is her unforgettable story.
July 15, 2025 Alex Summers

Photos Of Real Ship Graveyards That You Can Actually See Yourself

Nobody sets out to abandon a ship. But it happens. Some rust near cities, others sink quietly in lagoons. Most got left out of the story—unless you stumble on them or go digging (or swimming).
July 14, 2025 Peter Kinney
technology

Ranking The Most Tech-Advanced Countries In The World—According To Data

The top 20 most technologically advanced countries, ranked by their tech scores. From smart cities to self-driving cars, these countries are reshaping how we live.
July 18, 2025 Allison Robertson