March 5, 2025 | Peter Kinney

Caribbean Islands You May Not Have Heard Of


The Rest Of The World Is Still Finding Out

The Caribbean is one of the top travel destinations in the world, with millions flocking there every winter. While the bigger destinations offer more accommodations and dining options, they are also very busy and crowded. We'll look at some lesser-known Caribbean islands that offer a haven from the tourist crowds.

Caribbeanmsn

Saba

This lush rugged island in the Dutch Antilles is ideal for those looking for a more adventurous holiday. There are no beaches on the island, nor are there any of the usual trappings of the big tourist centers. The island is known for its breathtaking mountain airstrip, diverse marine life, and steep forest trails.

Caribbean Island Saba with Cloudy Sky in the Backgroundreefguard, Adobe Stock

Advertisement

Dominica

Despite its name, this island in the Lesser Antilles has nothing to do with the Dominican Republic. Maybe the similar name is responsible for why the island is so little-known to most tourists. A wonder for nature lovers, the lush rainforest of Dominica is criss-crossed by 365 rivers, and has numerous hot springs. There is also a black sand beach along with abundant diving locales.

Caribbean Island Dominica with Cloudy Sky in the Backgroundkorkeakoski, Adobe Stock

Isla Mujeres

This island is a mere eight miles from Cancún but it is almost a world apart. The island was once a fishing village that is now becoming known as a getaway from the crowds that flock the Mayan Riviera. The island offers very similar amenities to what you will see on the mainland, including archaeological treasures, snorkeling, local watering holes, but with a lot fewer people around.

Caribbean Island Isla Mujeres with Cloudy Sky in the Backgroundjdross75, Adobe Stock

Nevis

The smaller partner of the island nation of St Kitts and Nevis, Nevis is also by far the less populated of the pair. The laid-back atmosphere is free of busy traffic intersections, casinos, and strip malls. You’re as likely to encounter a monkey as a person on your excursion! The hotels are mostly refurbished mansions from the plantation days, giving the island an old-school charm. With hot springs, beaches, and forest trails, Nevis is a Caribbean gem.

Caribbean Island Nevis with Cloudy Sky in the Backgroundeqroy, Adobe Stock

Advertisement

Mustique, St Vincent And Grenadines

This destination is known for its upscale accommodations that attract very wealthy visitors; staying won’t be within everyone’s budget. Only 1,400 acres in area, the privately-owned and -operated island is known for the variety of its birds, the windswept rocky cliffs, and visits by celebrities.

Caribbean Island Mustique with Cloudy Sky in the Backgroundsandycrea, Adobe Stock

San Andrés, Colombia

Did you know that Colombia governs an island off the coast of Nicaragua? Most other North Americans don’t either. The island is a natural wonder offering white sand beaches, a coral reef, and amazing snorkeling. The island is near several parks and protected nature areas, including the Cueva de Morgan hidden cave. San Andres is popular with Colombians and is not as secluded as some of the others on this list—the island has a population of around 70,000.

Caribbean Island San Andrés with Cloudy Sky in the BackgroundWil.Amaya, Adobe Stock

Vieques, Puerto Rico

Another treasure of nature, the island of Vieques, just east of Puerto Rico, is unique for the bioluminescent waters of Mosquito Bay, the brightest of its kind in the world. The nocturnal glimmering of the water is caused by a rare breed of plankton. Aside from this, the island is known for its horses that run free, and great boating and scuba diving tours are available for those who want to leave the comfort of the beach.

Caribbean Island Vieques with Cloudy Sky in the BackgroundRobert, Adobe Stock

Advertisement

Culebra, Puerto Rico

Just north of Vieques lies the island of Culebra. Also part of Puerto Rico, the impossibly blue waters offer the whole range of watersports. The island is surrounded by numerous tiny secluded cays that provide a habitat for diverse marine life. Accessible by ferry from mainland Puerto Rico, the sand of Flamenco Beach is also home to some graffiti-covered army tanks, remnants of the island’s time as a US military base long ago.

Caribbean Island Culebra with Cloudy Sky in the Backgroundajfan25, Adobe Stock

Grenada

This island paradise south of Saint Vincent and Grenadines rarely comes up in conversations about best Caribbean destinations, but its natural beauty is matched only by its long and interesting history. The island hosts the relic Fort George left over from the colonial days when the island was a source of sugar cane, indigo, and today, nutmeg. The island’s airport has direct flights to and from Miami, New York, and Atlanta.

Caribbean Island Grenada with Cloudy Sky in the BackgroundNancy Pauwels, Adobe Stock

Martinique

This idyllic spot in the Lesser Antilles is a study in contrasts. With stretches of white sand beaches, the interior of the island rises across forest-shrouded slopes to the volcanic pinnacle of Mount Pelee. The island has been ravaged by the volcano’s wrath four times in recorded history, most recently in 1902 when there were two eruptions.

Caribbean Island Martinique with Cloudy Sky in the BackgroundDamien, Adobe Stock

Advertisement

St Croix, US Virgin Islands

This island is well connected to the mainland US by air, but though it’s on regular travel routes, the island is large enough that there are many spots to find privacy. There is a prize-winning rum distillery open for tours, while at the other end of the spectrum, Buck Island Reef National Monument offers outstanding snorkeling and diving.

Buck Island Reef National Monument St. Croix US Virgin IslandsMango Media, Adobe Stock

Anegada, British Virgin Islands

This coral island is a true marine paradise, with great beaches, diving, and fishing. Along with a diverse range of wildlife, there are numerous shipwrecks in the area to tempt more experienced divers. The island is connected by flights to San Juan, Puerto Rico and St Thomas in the US Virgin Islands.

Caribbean Island Anegada with Cloudy Sky in the BackgroundOverflightstock, Adobe Stock

Canouan, Grenadines

Like its Grenadine sibling Mustique (above), Canouan is another island that isn’t overrun with tourists, but you’ll be paying a lot more for that exclusivity. The wealthy island enclave is home to upscale amenities like a four-star beach hotel, spas, and an 18-hole golf course. Natural wonders include the beaches and one of the Caribbean’s largest coral reefs.

Caribbean Island Canouan with Clear Sky in the Backgroundalexandra, Adobe Stock

Advertisement

Bequia, St Vincent And Grenadines

The second-biggest island in the Grenadines, Bequia (pronounced beck-WAY) is a boater’s delight for its tranquil bays. Though the island does receive cruise ships, it's still recognized as one of the quietest islands in the chain. Home to a turtle sanctuary, all of the usual aquatic pursuits are here—or you can hike to the top of Mount Pleasant and enjoy the view of the islands.

Caribbean Island Bequia with Cloudy Sky in the Backgroundpkazmierczak, Adobe Stock

Cat Island, Bahamas

Offering all the natural splendors of the popular tropical island chain, but without the hordes of tourists, Cat Island is beautiful and also historic. The remnants of the original Arawak inhabitants are visible in cave systems here, along with ruins of slave homes from the old cotton plantation days. Eerie! The island’s Mount Alvernia is the highest point in the Bahamas.

Caribbean Island Cat Island with Cloudy Sky in the Backgroundpics721, Adobe Stock

Montserrat

This volcanic island saw major destruction as recently as 1995 when the capital city of Plymouth was ravaged by the fury of the Soufriere Hills volcano. Plymouth has been deserted ever since. With only one beach of any note, it’s understandable why fewer people visit the island. Tours of the volcano and numerous hiking trails are Montserrat’s main activities.

Caribbean Island Montserrat with Cloudy Sky in the Background.Pasop Photography, Adobe Stock

Advertisement

Cayman Brac, Cayman Islands

The beauty of this Caribbean jewel off the south coast of Cuba is tough to surpass. It offers great diving in addition to hiking and cave exploring along the prominent limestone bluffs. Cayman Brac is habitat to more than 200 tropical bird species—but though the birds have flocked here, tourists still have not.

Caribbean Island Cayman Brac with Cloudy Sky in the BackgroundWirestock, Adobe Stock

Sint Eustatius

This island in the Netherlands Antilles receives fewer than 6,000 tourists per year. In fact, it makes the nearby Netherlands island of Saba (above) look like a major tourist hub! Sponges and corals are the underwater highlight while an ascent of the 600-meter volcanic peak called The Quill will let you take in the island’s splendor.

Looking southeast across Statia toward the Quill on the island of Sint EustatiusWalter Hellebrand, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Iles Des Saintes, Guadeloupe

These gems of the French Caribbean are picturesque but quiet. Like all of the best Caribbean destinations, the Iles offer a great balance of activities on land and sea, with an array of plant and animal life including a sanctuary for seven different species of sea turtles.

Caribbean Islands Iles Des Saintes with Cloudy Sky in the BackgroundIryna Shpulak, Adobe Stock

Advertisement

Little Corn Island, Nicaragua

Nicaragua’s Corn Islands are not exactly a household name, so it’s no wonder Little Corn Island is one of the least visited on our list. Accessible only by boat from nearby Big Corn Island, Little Corn has no motor vehicles so it's incredibly peaceful. If you don’t mind getting everywhere using only your own two feet, this island’s beach and snorkeling hideaway is the place for you.

Caribbean Little Corn Island with Cloudy Sky in the BackgroundDennis Gutjahr, Adobe Stock

Salt Cay, Turks And Caicos

If something is small enough to call a cay, you know it’s small; Salt Cay is the smallest island in the lovely Turks and Caicos chain. Its inland pond was once a center for salt production, but the island has since become a haven for those looking for a relaxing Caribbean experience. Salt Cay is great for whale-watching, with its location on humpback whale migration routes.

Aerial view of Grand Turk, Salt Cay and Cotton Cay islandsGabriele Maltinti, Adobe Stock

Barbuda

The only two accommodations on this island north of Antigua are two luxury resorts. Accessible only by plane or three-hour boat ride, the island is sparsely settled, and its distance from Antigua means not as many people get here. Offering miles of beaches, reefs, shipwrecks, and an exotic bird sanctuary, Barbuda is the perfect mix of beauty, amenities, and seclusion from the crowds.

Caribbean Island Barbuda with Cloudy Sky in the BackgroundTamara, Adobe Stock

Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6


READ MORE

The True Story Of Saint Patrick

Saint Patrick is well-known as the Patron Saint of Ireland, but do you know how he became one? Explore the history of one of the world's most recognizable patron saints, who's death is marked by one of the world's most popular celebrations.
March 14, 2025 Jack Hawkins
Bathumb

The Bronze Age Collapse—What It Is And Why It Happened

Modern historians are still unravelling the mystery of the catastrophic Bronze Age collapse—and the evidence they've uncovered paints a chilling picture about the moment that civilization collapsed.
March 12, 2025 M. Clarke

The Maori People: New Zealand's Fierce Indigenous Tribe

The Maori are the oldest inhabitants of New Zealand—but years of forced assimilation following colonization brought their population to the brink of extinction. Read how the Maori reclaimed themselves and their sovereignty.
March 13, 2025 Jack Hawkins

The Best Airlines To Fly First Class—And What You Get On Them

Whether you're looking for ultimate privacy or top-tier service, these airlines are the best of the best when it comes to living it up in first class.
March 12, 2025 Andrew Matthesson

The Dread Pirate Barbarossa

Tales of pirates have long captured the imagination—but few know the story of the Dread Pirate Barbarossa, the scourge of the Mediterranean.
March 12, 2025 Jillian Kent

The Most Boring States In America—According To Data

Are you looking for some excitement in your life? Well, according to the data you aren't going to find it in any of these states.
March 12, 2025 Jesse Singer